Martin Luther: Sola Scriptura, Solus Christus, and the canon

Autores/as

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.59758/adv.2025.11.2.5670

Palabras clave:

Martin Luther, Biblical canon, sola Scriptura, solus Christus, canonicity

Resumen

This article provides an in-depth analysis of Martin Luther’s understanding of sola Scriptura and its profound connection to solus Christus, examining how these principles shaped his perspective on the biblical canon. Luther saw the expression “Word of God” as referring to Christ, the proclaimed Gospel, and the written Bible, which must unambiguously point to Christ to be considered authoritative. This view, in turn, led Luther to reject the canonicity of several books, particularly the Epistle of James, which he deemed nonapostolic and lacking a clear Christocentric message due to its emphasis on works. Finally, the article critiques Luther’s Christocentric test for canonicity as inconsistent and subjective, arguing for more objective, biblically grounded criteria.

Descargas

Los datos de descarga aún no están disponibles.

Referencias

1 W1 22:3. Quoted and translated in Robert D. Preus, “Luther and Biblical Infallibility”, in Inerrancy and the Church, John D. Hannah, ed. (Chicago: Moody Press, 1984), 116. Note the following abbreviations used in this article when quoting from the various editions of Martin Luther’s works:

WA = D. Martin Luther’s Werke, Kritische Gesamtausgabe (Weimar: Bohlau, 1883-2009); W1 = D. Martin Luther’s Sämtliche Schriften, ed. Johann Georg Walch, 1st edition (Halle: Johann Justinus Gebauer, 1740-1753); W2 = Martin Luther’s Sämtliche Schriften, ed. Johann Georg Walch, 2nd edition (St. Louis: Concordia, 1818-1930); LW = Luther’s Works, ed. Jaroslav Pelikan, Robert Fischer et al. (Philadelphia: Fortress, St. Louis: Concordia, 1955-1986).

2 W1 8:1303, quoted and translated in Preus, “Luther and Biblical Infallibility”, 116.

3 W1 9:1800, quoted and translated in Preus, “Luther and Biblical Infallibility”, 116.

4 W2 7:2095, quoted and translated in Preus, “Luther and Biblical Infallibility”, 119.

5 Cited by Robert D. Preus, “Luther and Biblical Infallibility”, 121, n. 68. See W. Bodamer, “Luthers Stellung zur Lehre von der Verbalinspiration”, Theologische Quartalschrift 34 (1936).

6 W2 3:1889; quoted and translated in Robert D. Preus, “Luther and Biblical Infallibility”, in Inerrancy and the Church, ed. John D. Hannah (Chicago: Moody Press, 1984), 119.

7 W1, 9:1071; quoted and translated in Preus, “Luther and Biblical Infallibility”, 118.

8 W2 9:1770; quoted and translated in Preus, “Luther and Biblical Infallibility”, 120.

9 Personal translation from WA 40:254; quoted in latin in Preus, “Luther and Biblical Infallibility”, 120, n. 61.

10 W1, 3:785.

11 W1, 3:1889. It should be noted, however, that “Luther did not teach a ‘mechanical inspiration’ or ‘dictation theory’ of inspiration” (Preus, “Luther and Biblical Infallibility”, 120).

12 LW 35, 368.

13 WA 12, 259; quoted and translated in Jillian E. Cox, “Martin Luther on the Living Word: Rethinking the Principle of Sola Scriptura,” Pacifica: Australasian Theological Studies 29, no. 1 (2016): 14.

14 LW 31:345.

15 LW 22:8.

16 See LW 22:7-29; also 1:17; 12:312.

17 LW 35:132.

18 LW 52:173.

19 LW 25:405.

20 LW 23:16.

21 LW 11:110.

22 WA, 3:63; quoted and translated in Preus, “Luther and Biblical Infallibility”, 113.

23 WA, 9:560; quoted and translated in Preus, “Luther and Biblical Infallibility”, 113.

24 See David W. Lotz, “Sola Scriptura: Luther on Biblical Authority”, Interpretation, Jul 1981, 263.

25 WA 18:606; quoted and translated in Preus, “Luther and Biblical Infallibility”, 112-113.

26 W2 17:1070; quoted and translated in Preus, “Luther: Word, Doctrine, and Confession”, 191.

27 W2 9: 1775; quoted and translated in Preus, “Luther: Word, Doctrine, and Confession”, 191.

28 W2 14:3, quoted and translated in Preus, “Luther and Biblical Infallibility”, 113.

29 LW 26:295.

30 LW 34:112.

31 LW 10:6. See also the following quote: “To read Holy Writ without faith in Christ is to walk in darkness” (WA 44:790; quoted and translated in Lewis W. Spitz, “Luther’s Sola Scriptura”, Concordia Theological Monthly 31 [1960], art. 84, 745).

32 LW, 35:394.

33 See M. Rue, Luther and the Scriptures (Columbus, OH: The Wartburg Press, 1944), 45.

34 LW 35:394.

35 LW 35:395.

36 LW 35:398.

37 LW 35:398.

38 LW 35:399.

39 Jaroslav Pelikan, Luther the Expositor, Luther’s Works Companion Volume (St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 1959), 87-88.

40 Martin Luther, The Tabletalk of Martin Luther, trans. and ed. William Hazlitt (Scotland: Christian Focus Publications, 2003), 102.

41 LW 33:110.

42 Paul O’Callaghan, “Solus Christus and Sola Scriptura: The Christological Roots of Martin Luther’s Interpretation of Scripture”, Annales Theologici 31 (2017): 467.

43 WA 2:425, translated in Glen E. Zweck, “Luther on James: A Curious Oversight”, Lutheran Theological Review IX (Academic Year 1996-97): 55.

44 LW 35:396.

45 See Zweck, “Luther on James: A Curious Oversight”, 67.

46 See Lotz, “Sola Scriptura”, 264.

47 An example of this could be Caiaphas. See John 11:49-51; 18:34.

48 LW 35:397 n. 55.

49 LW 35:397 n. 55.

50 “Many have tried hard to make James agree with Paul, as also Melanchthon did in his Apology, but not seriously. These do not harmonize: Faith justifies, and faith does not justify. To him who can make these two agree I will give my doctor’s cap and I am willing to be called a fool”. WA Tischreden 3, no. 3292 a. Translated in Rue, Luther and the Scripture), 42-43.

51 WA Tischreden 5, no. 5854. Translated in M. Rue, Luther and the Scriptures, 43.

52 LW 34:317. The priest referred to here was said to have received the visit of a duchess. Being in the need of warming the room, the priest began placing several wooden statues of the apostles into his stove. James was the last one left, and as the priest pushed his statue into the fire, he exclaimed: “Now bend over, Jimmy, you must go into the stove; no matter if you were the pope or all the bishops, the room must become warm” (LW 34:317 n. 21).

53 See Rue, Luther and the Scriptures, 44. Also Zweck, “Luther on James: A Curious Oversight”, 59.

54 WA Tischreden 5, no. 5443. Translated in M. Rue, Luther and the Scriptures, 43.

55 LW 35:362.

56 For a more detailed discussion on this distinction in Luther see Zweck, “Luther on James: A Curious Oversight”, 61-63.

57 Lotz, “Sola Scriptura”, 273.

58 LW 35:395.

59 LW 35:337 n. 1.

60 The Lutheran Study Bible, Edward A. Engelbrecht, ed. (St. Louis: Concordia Publishing House, 2009), 2132.

61 Michael Rogness, “A canon within the canon? Yes: proclaim Christ”, Word & World, Aut 2006, 436. See also Lotz, “Sola Scriptura”, 272; and Pelikan, Luther the Expositor, 87-88.

62 WA 5:463.

63 W2 19:20, quoted and translated in Preus, “Luther and Biblical Infallibility”, 133.

64 WA 26:449; quoted and translated in Preus, “Luther and Biblical Infallibility”, 130.

65 W2 3:9; 12:1037; 20:146.

66 W2 20:153.

67 Martin Luther, The Tabletalk of Martin Luther, 102.

68 See Lotz, “Sola Scriptura”, 273. Luther, at times, seems to appeal to the authority of “the ancients” (see LW 35:394, 395). However, although Origen and Eusebius may have shown doubts as to the canonicity of certain books of the Bible (such as James or Revelation), many others in the early church considered them canonical (See Martin Foord, “The ‘Epistle of Straw’: Reflections on Luther and the Epistle of James”, Themelios 45, no. 2 [2020]: 297-298). However, more importantly, as this article demonstrates, Luther’s primary arguments centered on the Christocentric principle of canonicity, rather than the authority of the Church or the Church Fathers.

69 Paul Althaus, The Theology of Martin Luther (Philadelphia: Fortress Press, 1966), 85, 336.

70 Luther identified the Papacy as the second beast of Revelation 13 (LW 35:399-411). For a more nuanced treatment of Luther’s view on Revelation, see Charles A. Gieschen, “The Relevance of the Homologoumena and Antilegomena Distinction for the New Testament Canon Today: Revelation as a Test Case”, Concordia Theological Quarterly 79 (2015): 286-289.

71 John Peckham, Canonical Theology: The Biblical Canon, Sola Scriptura, and Theological Method (Grand Rapids, MI: Eerdmans, 2016), 37.

72 See, Peckham, Canonical Theology, 35; also Michael J. Kruger, The Question of Canon: Challenging the Status Quo in the New Testament Debate (Downers Grove, IL: InterVarsity, 2013), 153.

73 Kruger, The Question of Canon, 153-154.

74 For a more nuanced treatment of the authorship of James, see Douglas Moo, The Letter of James. Pillar New Testament Commentary (Grand Rapids, MI: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co., 2000), 9-11.

75 For example, James 2:8 quotes from Leviticus 19:18; James 2:11 quotes Exodus 20:13-15; James 2:23 quotes from Genesis 15:6; James 4:6 quotes from Proverbs 3:34; and he also alludes to Jeremiah 9:23, Isaiah 40:6 and Job 14:2 (in 1:10); to Genesis 22:9 (in 2:21); to Joshua 2 and 6 (in 2:25); to Job 1 and 42 (in 5:11); and to 1 Kings 17:1 and 18:41 (in 5:17-18).

76 Moo, The Letter of James, 27.

Descargas

Publicado

17-12-2025

Número

Sección

Artículos

Categorías

Cómo citar

Martin Luther: Sola Scriptura, Solus Christus, and the canon. (2025). Advenimiento, 11(2), 56-70. https://doi.org/10.59758/adv.2025.11.2.5670

Artículos similares

1-10 de 17

También puede Iniciar una búsqueda de similitud avanzada para este artículo.